More Than Our Marketable Output
On Production, Value, and Celebrating Toads
Kia-Beth Bennett
11/8/202610 min read
produce: to give birth or rise to; to cause to have existence or to happen; to bear, make, or yield something
production: a work presented on the stage or screen or over the air; the act or process of producing; total output esp. of a commodity or an industry
value: the monetary worth of something: marketable price; to rate or scale in usefulness, importance or general worth; the relation of one part in a picture to another with respect to lightness and darkness
~ Merriam-Webster, 2002
Senna-Bean is enjoying the North Pasture this Autumn, filled as it is with new culinary delights.
I grew up on a farm that was, in part, a market operation. I learned to make change behind a folding table; I practiced public speaking by teaching strangers about Early Wonder tomatoes. Many of my most pleasant memories were created whilst running between stands, accepting pumpkin bread from ‘Dawn the baker’ and tossing pennies into the village fountain. Later on, as sales were plummeting, my family reduced our presence at market and built an on-site farmstand, filling it with herbs, meats, eggs, and vegetables. We hung a pride flag, an Earth flag, and fifteen narrow wooden signs advertising available wares.
That first year, the farmstand brought more traffic and income than heading the half-hour to the market had. It also became a better way to know our more immediate neighbors, or at least the folk who drove by every day. A huge portion of our previous customer base was at least two towns over; was made of people who never actually saw the farm.
With time, the farmstand expanded outside its original purpose. Being on-site meant we could fill the building with bouquets, just for fun. We could turn a few shelves into a public library. We could pile stacks of greenhouse pots with a “Help Yourself” sign out front. I began to see the farmstand as not a marketing technique, but a part of the farm’s community outreach.
This year, I made a mild attempt to stock the stand with eggs, as there was an abundance all Spring. Soon, though, the decision to let hens nest reduced egg-gathering, and I was left with empty shelves in an otherwise very nice little building. I decided, what the heck? Let’s devote the whole place to bibliophiles.
So now the stand is the biggest Little Library I’ve ever seen, filled with mystery novels, jigsaw puzzles, seed catalogues, coloring books, and more, and I’ve arranged with a local ‘Big Library’ to swap out less popular books. I am ecstatic - as an introvert, this creates opportunities for low-contact culture work. The schoolkids and I can wave to each other as they peruse picture books, and I rarely have to put on my Market Face, as I’m no longer selling to passers-by.
Upending the expectations society has of a farm(stand), however, comes with complications. Namely, the conversations necessary between myself and those who seek to be paying customers, looking for a specific product. Case in point: this July, a couple drove up looking for sweet corn. It being a Sunday, they were unable to patronize Amish farm stands, so when they saw we were open, assumed it was worth the stop. Seeing a lack of vegetables, the visitors asked, “So what do you produce?”
I was already upset with their brusque attitudes and their car-window-jumping dog. I flat-out told them we “are a regenerative operation healing from five years of trauma, and while we’ll be butchering pigs soon, I don’t think we’re the farm for them.” They left.
A few months later, I and a student were harvesting pears, of which there is a plethora this year. I was encouraging her to try each variety, and we were discussing said plethora, how processing all the fruit would be too much for me, how I should set out a few boxes at the stand for folks to snag, how the language of gifting isn’t always accessible to those speaking market tongues. We paused to find more empty baskets, and an odd confluence happened. An area biker stopped by, asking what we sell, and Lyndsay arrived with boxes of smoked pork she’d processed for us in exchange for a hogling. I was thrown off guard. Here I was, discussing the language of non-market relationships, only to be suddenly confronted with examples of both market and non-market interactions. I had no idea what to say to the biker; all I wanted to do was slide into the safety of the relationship of mutual care that Lyndsay and I have built. What do I sell? I no longer knew how to answer that.
These experiences are part of a series of questions I’ve been exploring this year, about worth, production, relationships, value and the sort of culture in which I want to live, farm and explore. There are easy answers, there are hard answers, but there are no answers that can be fully articulated in brief, self-contained conversations. Everything deserves a deep dive, a level of attention that I’ve been unable to afford in the past. That said, perhaps in the next 2,000 or so words, we can dissect these thoughts together.
“What Do You Produce?”
A few rare folk will ask this out of curiosity, but generally, people aren’t looking for a farm description; they’re actually wondering, “What can we get from you? Is it something we want?” That creates a very specific transaction of demands and requires an easily digestible answer. It’s also indicative of folks’ general perception of what a farm is and does, with people understanding our work only through the lens of a finished, packaged product and its intended role. Even the more considerate questions (How are the animals raised? Do you spray pesticides?) are more about the food the asker will consume, not the spirit of the farm. Never has a human asked me, “What sort of relationship do you and the trees have? How often do you visit the baby blackbirds? Is the farm a safe place for turtles to thrive?”
What if I responded a bit more holistically, in a way that gave more answers than were questions asked? What if I said…
“Well, this year, the pond supported a bumper crop of American toads, and now is home to dozens of American bullfrog polywogs! And oh, the milk snakes are doing so well this season, really healthy. Are you interested in insects? You’ll be happy to hear that the Necrophilia americana just went wild - the tightening circle of life and death here is truly rejuvenating the whole farm. Ah, you’re looking at the livestock. Yes, this year we produced a dearth of hoglings, but it came with the understanding that excess walnut hulls cause silent miscarriages. And check out those pastures! Unhealthy levels of rain, and still the farm soils held.
Oh, you were looking for something more...human oriented? I mean, this farm produced two fully repaired wheelbarrows - that’s significant. I could talk about the production of hours of contemplation of the role of a solo-farmer farm during a climate crisis under rising fascism. Too much? How about this: we produced something truly rare this year, one-of-a-kind - the improved mental health of the farmer!! Priceless!!”
Priceless.
Price. Less.
Do consumers want something priceless, something unmonetized, something untranslatable by capitalism?
The truth is that by a number of ecological standards, we’re likely the most productive farm in the valley. Without exaggeration, we’re the most diverse farm on this road. But when the language of an economy and thus society can only describe measurable output of physical, marketable products, the creation of “that feeling of quiet awe as the fog lifts from the hill” is never part of the equation.
Relationships: Transactional, Intersectional, Intentional
Imagine you walk up to a farmstand. You see some luscious tomatoes, with a colorful sign listing their value at $3.00 a pound. You weigh out a pound, pull out some cash, thank the farmer and leave. Perhaps there are a few more steps in the process: you check whether the tomatoes are pastes or slicers, or you ask if they were grown organically. The farmer might offer you a bag. Ultimately, even if you return the next day, the current relationship you and the farmer share is transactional. They have something you want, you must give a specific amount of money to get it.
Imagine this instead: you walk up to a farmstand. You start asking about the farmer, how they’re doing. You get curious and excited, and eventually, the farmer says, “If you’d like to learn more, you could follow me as I finish chores.” You agree - now you’re invested. You grab a watering can, offer to move the hose. You relish the rich smells of the garden soil and the vibrancy of the marigold blossoms. You catch your breath as a hummingbird hovers near your left ear; the farmer smiles, commenting that that hummingbird has lived in the area for years. Your mind whirls when you realize that the bird and the farmer actually share a relationship. At the end of the visit, as you turn to leave, the farmer pushes a heavy bag of tomatoes into your arms. It’s a gift, they say. You’re a part of the farm now. You suddenly realize that those tomatoes grew in the bone-meal compost that squished beneath your feet a moment ago, that the tiny friendly flower flies you saw helped pollinate them. You’d just touched the plants’ branches and listened to the farmer talk about the legacy of that variety. You’re in love, a little bit, and it barely took an hour. You’ll be back tomorrow, you decide. You have an appointment with a hummingbird.
I fault no one for working within the market system when that’s all we’ve been given or taught. But those lessons remove from the picture that which they can’t monetize. $3.00, or $10.00, or $50.00 a pound doesn’t account for the bones of the beloved cattle, broken down into calcium-rich dust for the plants to absorb. Nor does it account for the experiences you, the visitor, might bring to the farm. But if it’s not considering those arguably important aspects, do those aspects, well...count? If it’s not a skill listable on your resume, is it of value? And if you don’t have a resume, does that mean you’re valueless?
In a system that dictates what matters and how, if someone is valueless, we’re asked to not care about them. If a tomato is rotting, or a person isn’t working a nine-to-five, we’re encouraged to turn away, to throw away. No value = no caring. When we care, we start to act differently. Caring means we might enter into a relationship, one that serves more than our stomachs, more than ourselves. No caring = no relationships. And without relationships - without intentional, repeated acts of mutual respect and love - we cease to recognize the importance of those around us. No relationships = no value.
So we create a measuring system that assigns value without relationship, deepening the divide until our framework for interactions is built on the idea that if someone can’t give us what we want, we can ignore their existence, their needs, their inherent value.
What do you produce?
Relationships. We produce a magnificently woven web of powerful, multi-faceted, complex, unusual, love-filled relationships. We produce conversations between sheep and farmer, farmer and green heron, green heron and pond, pond and toad, toad and crawdad, crawdad and stone, stone and soil, soil and milkweed, milkweed and pollinator, pollinator and pollen, pollen and seed, seed and ant, ant and snake, snake and fungal network, fungal network and apple tree, apple tree and fruit, fruit and sheep and back around again.
Priceless.
Price. Less.
Not value less.
Limitations and Opportunities
I’m spitballing here, but I feel confident estimating that at least 98.5% of North Country humans have never tasted the rich sweetness of a roasted wild parsnip. Wild parsnips are considered dangerous, and they are invasive in this region. Their sap, when released onto one’s skin, reacts with sunlight to create phytophotodermatitis. Particularly sensitive folk can land in the hospital with second-degree burns. When the plants are in flower, it makes sense to avoid them.
Wild parsnip is barely two genes (again, spitballing, I’m not a geneticist) away from domesticated parsnip. The crop farmers grow has less toxic sap and straighter, more uniform roots. They’re probably close enough in nutritional quality to not make a huge difference, but they’re a perfect example of agricultural and market selection of a plant that is nowadays seeded in straight, weed-free rows, and often heavily sprayed.
I don’t bother planting domesticated parsnips anymore, because the wild parsnips that the cows eat and fertilize grow strong, healthy, and taste delicious with butter, squash and maple syrup. I’ve learned to recognize the value of and build a relationship with a maligned plant the market ignores. But what if you’ve never been taught such magic? If you’re unfamiliar with wild parsnips, what happens when domesticated ones are no longer at the supermarket? Crop loss from climate change is inevitable, which means that the foods we’ve been taught to value, the foods we do have relationships with, aren’t going to be as accessible. Surviving on a climatically chaotic planet might mean choking down our least favorite vegetable, for lack of literally any other food. It might mean valuing non-market foods is something we do kicking and screaming, mourning the lack of January-sold strawberries. Thriving, however, could mean we understand value outside of what was once easily purchased. Instead of entering a farmstand with a strict expectation of sweetcorn, you meet a farmer and learn how each of you can tend to the other. You go home with a basket of food you’ve never eaten but now know how to prepare, and the farmer gets to rest, because you helped fix the barn roof.
I know I’m painting a rosy picture. I said at the beginning that there are no easily articulated, shallow-waters answers, and everything I’ve written is far more complex than I’ll ever truly be able to describe. But amazing things can happen when we stop asking, “What do you sell? What can you do for me? How many pieces of green paper do you want in exchange?” and start asking “Who are you? What relationships are being formed here? Do I want to be a part of this work? Can we value each other?” Amazing things can happen when we sink a garden fork into humus-y loam, pull out a gangly white root, and meet, for the first time, a wild parsnip.




The Tiny Mow-Mow is the most scrumdiddlyumptious addition to the family.
With love,
Kia-Beth
